NOTE: Emory's first year of varsity competition in the NCAA was the 2019-20 school year.
| Year | Average | UAA | NCAA | Coach |
| 2020 | 338.2 | Cancelled | Cancelled | Katie Futcher |
| 2021 | 321 | Cancelled | 7th Place | Katie Futcher |
| 2022 | 295.5 | 1st | National Champions | Katie Futcher |
| 2023 | 302.4 | 1st | 5th Place | Katie Futcher |
**End of 2020 season cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemic
**2021 season abbreviated due to COVID-19 pandemic